Smoked Turkey with Herb and Garlic Butter

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Smoked Turkey blanketed in a fresh herb and garlic butter rub and smoked on a Big Green Egg is a wonderful choice for Thanksgiving or any occasion where your oven might be space-challenged.

If you have never smoked a whole turkey before, you will be surprised at just how easy it is and how moist and tender the result is.

Smoked turkey on a platter with garnish.

Smoking a whole turkey is a great option for Thanksgiving or Christmas, especially in the South and other areas where the weather is still balmy. Also, smoking solves the puzzle of cooking for a crowd when you have just one oven.

Smoked turkey also tastes and looks fantastic! I smoked this turkey on a Big Green Egg, but you can use this same recipe on any kamado-type smoker or whatever type of grill you have.

The first turkey I ever smoked was on an inexpensive charcoal grill that didn’t even have a lid. I had to cover the whole thing with aluminum foil to keep the smoke in, but the taste was incredible!

Jump to:

Why you will love this recipe:
Ingredient notes:
Step-by-step directions:
Recipe variations:
Recipe FAQs:
More Thanksgiving dinner menu ideas:
📋 Recipe:
Smoked Turkey with Herb and Garlic Butter

Why you will love this recipe:

It contains easy step-by-step directions, whether you are using a Big Green Egg or another type of grill, with photos and tips to ensure you have a perfect turkey.
Optional instructions to dry brine your turkey are included.
Smoking your turkey on a grill or smoker makes your oven free for the all-important side dishes and desserts.

Ingredient notes:

A raw turkey and ingredients for a herb and garlic butter rub.

Turkey – is the guest of honor at this party. Serving turkey on Thanksgiving is a time-honored tradition with many families. For smoking, it’s best to stick with a ten to twelve-pound turkey.
Fresh herbs – sage, rosemary, and thyme give the compound butter an amazingly fresh, herby flavor, and the smell when you are chopping them is intoxicating. All pair beautifully with turkey and enhance its flavor.
Butter – when mixed with fresh herbs and garlic, butter transforms a regular smoked turkey into an unforgettable holiday treat!
Garlic – adds its tasty garlicky essence to the compound butter rub.
Kosher salt and ground black pepper – combine to enhance all of the other flavors of the turkey and bring them all together in this smoked masterpiece.
Lemons – fresh lemon halves are stuffed in the cavity of the turkey while it smokes and brings a fresh citrusy element to this recipe.

Step-by-step directions:

If you are using a Big Green Egg, fill the basket with charcoal and preheat the grill to 350 °F without inserting the plate setter. Once it comes up to 350 °F., sprinkle one cup of your favorite wood chips or a few small chunks of wood over the coals. You do not need to soak the wood first.
Add the plate setter with the legs facing up. Place a drip pan filled with water on the plate setter, and finally, add the grill grate on top of the plate setter legs.
If you are using another type of grill, follow the manufacturer’s directions or set up the grill for indirect grilling. Nestle a drip pan filled with water in the middle of the charcoal to catch the turkey drippings. Light the charcoal and preheat the grill to 350 °F.
Remove the giblets and any other parts from the cavity of the bird and save them to make gravy or turkey stock. If there is any type of plastic holding the legs together, or a plastic instant-read thermometer, remove that as well. Use a paper towel and pat dry the turkey all over, including inside the cavity.

Using a paper towel to dry off a turkey.

Sprinkle salt and pepper inside and outside of the bird.

Mix the softened butter with the garlic and one-fourth cup each of the chopped sage, thyme, and rosemary.

Two sticks of butter in a bowl along with herbs and garlic.

Use your hands or a small spatula and rub one-half of the butter herb mixture over the top and sides of the bird. Use the handle of a wooden spoon and gently loosen the skin over the breast so you can put some of the butter between the skin and the breast.

A raw turkey covered with a herb and garlic butter rub.

Stuff the remaining herbs and lemon halves in the cavity. Optional: tie the legs together with kitchen string.
Place the bird on the grill grate and if you are using them, insert temperature probes in the thickest part of the breast and thigh, not touching the bone. Close the grill lid or cover the entire grill with heavy-duty aluminum foil if you don’t have a lid.

A turkey on a BGE with temperature probes.

Maintain the grill heat at 350 °F (depending on what type of grill you are using, you may have to add additional charcoal), and plan to smoke the gobbler for about three hours or 13-15 minutes per pound. About every 30 minutes or so, brush the bird with the remaining herb and garlic butter mixture. Add additional water to the drip pan if needed.

The bird is done when an instant-read thermometer inserted into the thickest part of the breast and thigh registers 165 °F. Keep in mind that it will continue to cook even after you remove it from the grill. The temperature will rise another five to ten degrees while it rests, so plan for that.

There are many variables when smoking a turkey, so be sure to use a digital instant-read meat thermometer to check for doneness. I like to pull mine off the grill at about 160 °F. After removing it from the grill, place the bird on a platter, cover it loosely with foil and let it rest for at least 30 minutes before carving and serving.

Recipe variations:

You can use this same recipe to smoke a turkey breast, legs, or thighs. You just might have some leftover rub, and it will not take as long.
You can also use an injector and inject your favorite seasoning solution.
Instead of lemons, you could stuff the turkey with apple slices and onions.
Instead of dry brining, you could use the wet brining method.

Recipe FAQs:

Should I brine before smoking?

You don’t have to brine your bird first, but doing so will give you a more tender and juicy result. I recommend dry-brining. Dry-brining is much easier than submerging a large turkey in a bucket of water and then trying to figure out how to store it in the refrigerator overnight.

Also, if you are going to brine, be sure to stay away from kosher birds, which have been pre-salted, as well as self-basting birds, which have been injected with a salt solution. If in doubt, read the label.

How to dry brine a turkey?

1. Remove the neck and giblets and pat the fowl dry with a paper towel.

2. Combine one-third of a cup of kosher salt and one teaspoon of pepper in a bowl. Sprinkle this mixture all over the bird and inside the cavity. Try to put some of the salt mixture under the skin on the breast.

3. Put the gobbler on a large dish and refrigerate, uncovered, for two to three days. Three days will yield the best results. If you can’t stand the thought of it being uncovered in your refrigerator, cover it loosely with a piece of cheesecloth.

4. The longer, the better. I know it seems strange to leave the meat uncovered in the refrigerator, but it will help dry the skin out, which will, in turn, make it extra crispy. Before smoking, let the bird sit out for one hour to come to room temperature. You do not need to rinse it before adding the rub and cooking it.

What’s the best wood for smoking?

Choose a wood that will complement the mild flavor of the meat without overpowering it. I like to use oak or pecan or fruit woods such as cherry, apple, peach, or pear.

How to keep the meat moist while it’s smoking?

I like to smoke my turkey at 350 degrees F., so it doesn’t dry out and take too long to cook. Also, keeping water in the drip pan helps as it adds a moisture element. Brining it first also ensures it stays moist.

How long does it take to smoke a turkey at 350 °F?

This is a hard one, and the answer is it depends! There are many variables, such as: how well your grill maintains an even temperature, how big the bird is, how often you open the grill lid, the outside air temperature, the bird’s internal temperature, etc.

Generally, It will take about 13-15 minutes a pound or two and a half to three hours to smoke a twelve-pound gobbler.

The most important thing is to use a meat thermometer which can monitor the internal temperature and let you know when it is done, rather than timing it.

What’s the best way to monitor the internal temperature of the turkey?

A good leave-in meat thermometer eliminates the guesswork and will allow you to cook your turkey perfectly every time. I use a ThermoWorks Signals BBQ Thermometer, which pairs with my phone so I can monitor the temperatures inside while the bird cooks outside.

It also comes with four probes so I can monitor the internal temperature in several different areas as well as the temperature of the grill itself.

Signals also has an add-on piece of equipment called Billows that I use as well. It has a temperature control fan that keeps the grill at a constant temperature.

I have no relationship with this company, and this is not a paid advertisement for these products. I just really like them and think you will too!

How long does it take to thaw a turkey?

The most important thing here is to plan ahead! According to the USDA, a frozen twelve-pound bird will take three to four days to thaw in the refrigerator.

This means if you are planning on brining it too, you should purchase your turkey at least a week before you plan to smoke it! Also, be sure to put it in a container while it is thawing in the refrigerator to prevent the juices from dripping on other foods or running all over your fridge’s shelves.

More Thanksgiving dinner menu ideas:

Trying to decide what to serve with your smoked turkey? Check out these collections of some of my most popular recipes, as well as recipes from other bloggers for the ultimate Thanksgiving feast:

Don’t forget dessert! For a sweet ending to your Thanksgiving meal, check out these awesome recipes: 40 Best Desserts for Thanksgiving 2022 and 40 Best Non-Traditional Thanksgiving Desserts.
And you know I wouldn’t leave you high and dry with a refrigerator full of leftovers without my collection of 27 Best Thanksgiving Leftover Recipes and Menu Ideas
Here are even more Thanksgiving recipes and Christmas recipes, and menu ideas.
And finally, if you like recipes like this for smoked meat, you might also like these family favorites: